I recently had a conversation with my sister's boyfriend about putting a guy in the friend zone.
We were dissecting why I felt the need to dash this gentleman's romantic dream that was probably no more than a desire to get me drunk and take advantage of me, when Donna's man asked, "Was he not aggressive enough?"
It was then that I realized men and women have wildly different ideas about what it takes to make a love connection happen between two people.
Men, as it turns out, are completely delusional. You guys actually believe that you can charm the pants off any girl you want as long as you have enough confidence. In the past, when my male friends made obscene comments about hot girls they saw, I used to think they were just dreaming out loud. Now I know better. Apparently, all guys are told at some point in their lives that even if a girl is way, way out of your league, she'll still let you stick it in her if you're funny enough. This explains why most comedians are hideously ugly. They got the memo and they are really taking it to heart.
Let me just clear this up right now. Having a great personality will get you to a certain point, but if she's not attracted to you, it ain't gonna happen.
If you have a crush on a girl and she put you in the friend zone, it's not because you didn't make your intentions known. It's not because you were too nice. It's not because you didn't make her laugh. It's because she didn't find you fuckable.
Pick-up artists will insist that you can always turn it around if you know what you're doing. After all, most of them aren't particularly handsome, or wealthy, or anything special. Yet they manage to get laid all the time because they never wait too long to close the deal. While I will agree that there is a window of opportunity for avoiding the friend zone by letting a girl know you're interested early on, I will also say that in order for any guy to take advantage of this window, the girl had to have been 50/50 about fucking him in the first place. You don't have to look like James Franco or have tons of cash, but if you're decent in either area and you don't act like a pussy every time you see her, then yes, you do have a shot. If, on the other hand, you're an Average Joe and you show zero personality the first, say, three times you see this girl, then you, my dear, have just bought yourself a one-way ticket to the friend zone. In this instance the pick-up artists would be right. You had a chance, and you blew it.
There are a couple of things, however, that the pick-up artists forgot to mention.
First, pick-up tactics only work in situations where the guy is totally average. Average looks, average income, average achievement. The girl he likes is on the fence until he overpowers her with his irresistible manliness, pushing her over the edge and making her want him. That's all good and well for the average guy, but those rules don't apply to anyone else. If a man is gorgeous, he'll get laid. If he's rich, he'll get laid. If he's famous, he'll get laid. A dude that possesses all three traits - the trifecta of female desire - can talk about cloud shapes all day and women will still gladly jump in his bed. But a dude that weighs 500 pounds, works as a cashier at McDonald's, owes thousands of dollars in gambling debt, and lives in his mother's basement is not getting laid no matter how witty and clever he is.
Second, and more importantly, what any female considers "average" changes from chick to chick. The hotter the girl, the higher the bar.* You might be a 7 in your Weight Watchers meetings, but where you rank on Natalie Portman's scale is most likely going to be totally different. There will be times during your quest for love when you never stood a chance to begin with. I wish more guys would realize this and move on rather than embarrass themselves trying to get with a supermodel because some so-called dating expert told them it was possible.
If you're the type of guy that can get almost any woman he wants, chances are you have a pretty face, or a fat paycheck, or both. A rocking personality definitely helps, but it does not guarantee that you'll get anywhere. If you are an attractive rich guy who constantly finds himself in the friend zone, then you need to reexamine your interactions with women because you are definitely doing something wrong. Or maybe you're just gay and haven't come out yet, which is fine and actually makes more sense. If you assess yourself honestly and conclude that you are indeed average
to the women you are interested in, then you should be successful at least half the time as long as you put in a little effort. For the rest of you, know that there's very little you can do to change the mind of a woman that never wanted to screw you in the first place. Think of it this way: the level of rejection you experience is directly related to the level of approach you used. Use an aggressive approach, and she'll turn you down. Use a soft approach, and she'll put you in the friend zone. If you want to avoid both outcomes, I suggest you find a way to make yourself above average in her eyes.
*I'd like to point out that smarter girls also have higher standards for the men they date, but it's been my experience that most guys - I said most! - don't give two shits about a girl's intelligence.